Before the First Trade
Before I turned 35, I became a private banking client. That experience taught me a lot. One lesson: bankers won’t tell you how much the order of things matters. The CFP Financial Planning Process provides the guideline: understand the client, identify the goals, analyze the course of action, develop financial planning recommendations, present the financial plan, implement the recommendations, and monitor progress & update.
If you are the second or third generation preparing to inherit, or you are about to arrange an inheritance for your children, slow down, don’t jump into buying a product, and think about the above sequence.
Why the Order Gets Inverted
Large private banks typically have a relationship manager (RM) who is in charge of your account, not your plan. The account paperwork makes that explicit: every decision is recorded as yours, because, generally, the bank does not have a fiduciary responsibility, versus a CFP professional who does.
The bank's process is built around the account, not around your family. The account opens first and then the investments are selected. The goals, plan, and course of action? Not discussed. Sometimes the implications come up years later—maybe when it is already too late.
Assets bought in the wrong name or held in the wrong country can bring estate tax, reporting obligations, or a fight with local inheritance rules. Fixing these after the fact costs more than anyone budgeted for.
A Version I See Often
A business owner, 60, with a company in Asia and factories in Southeast Asia doing well, opens an account at a private bank in Singapore. Within the first month the investments are purchased: US stocks, a few high yield bond funds, some fixed coupon notes (FCNs). A year later, he wants to transfer assets to his son, who works in the United States.
The problems arrive all at once. The bond funds, which were supposed to pay a regular dividend, have declined in value significantly, the fixed coupon notes are locked-in for several years, and now that someone is finally looking at the account through a US lens, the US stocks in the father’s own name are US-situs assets, exposed to the US estate tax above a $60,000 exemption, regardless of which country the custodian is located within.
You have to know what your goals are and what the plan is before choosing a structure, and only then decide what to buy, and in whose name.
In the end, the investments were taken apart and rebuilt under a different holding structure. It took a significant amount of time, plus transaction costs that never needed to be paid.
The Right Order
- Understand the Client’s Personal and Financial Circumstance. Draw up the family balance sheet: every asset, where it is, whose name it is in, which country’s rules apply. Every person who is a US person, tax resident, or who might move there.
- Identify and select goals. What the money is for, who inherits, how much liquidity to keep, how much risk to take, and who decides if one day you are unable to make the decisions.
- Analyze the client’s current course of action and potential alternative course(s) of action. Where are you on track for? Is this where you want to go?
- Develop the financial planning recommendation(s). Based on current circumstances, what changes make sense to initiate to optimize your finances.
- Present the financial planning recommendation(s). Discuss in detail the pros and cons of each recommendation and how it can make sense for your family.
- Implement the financial planning recommendation(s). Lawyers who practice in the relevant jurisdictions draft what the plan calls for: wills in each country, a trust if one is needed, ownership that fits where the heirs will live.
- Monitor progress and update. A discretionary mandate under a written investment policy, reviewed on a schedule. Make changes when life inevitably shifts—particularly for expats!
That was my own experience. I wanted to map the assets, set up the structure, and then invest. The bank was ready to implement on day one. The previous steps weren't ignored; someone came by to talk about structure briefly, and then the conversation soon returned to what to buy.
At Avrio, we act as fiduciaries for every client. We discuss our clients’ goals, family situation, and passports, among other items. We determine where assets are allocated, choose the custodian that is best aligned with our client’s requirements, and implement the plan.
There is a lot to prepare before you set sail. Go through a systematic process, then leave port, and don't let anyone hurry you. The next time you walk into a private bank, don't rush to sign the first trade. Ask your banker: how does this investment fit into my overarching plan, goals, and direction in life? Do you have a fiduciary responsibility to your clients? If the answer makes you pause, that is the time to reach out to one of our wealth planners. Ideally before the first trade.
--
35 岁之前,我自己就成了私人银行的客户。那段经历教了我很多。其中一课:银行家不会告诉你,事情的先后顺序有多重要。CFP 财务规划流程给了一套准则:了解客户、确认目标、分析行动方案、制定财务规划建议、提出财务规划方案、执行建议,以及持续跟踪与更新。
如果你是准备继承的第二代、第三代,或是正要为子女安排传承,请放慢脚步,不要急着买产品,先想一想上面这个顺序。
为什么顺序会被倒过来
大型私人银行通常会指派一位客户经理(RM),他负责的是你的账户,不是你的规划。开户文件把这一点写得很明白:每一个决定都记录为你自己做的,因为一般来说,银行不承担信义义务,而 CFP 专业人士则承担信义义务。
银行的流程是围绕账户建立的,不是围绕你的家庭。先开户,再选投资标的。目标、规划、行动方案呢?没有讨论。有时候,后果要好几年后才浮现——可能已经来不及了。
资产用错了名义持有,或放错了国家,可能带来遗产税、申报义务,或是与当地继承规则的冲突。事后再补救,花的钱比任何人预算的都多。
我常看到的一种情况
一位 60 岁的企业主,公司在亚洲,工厂在东南亚,生意做得不错,在新加坡一家私人银行开了户。第一个月内投资就买齐了:美国股票、几只高收益债券基金、一些固定票息票据(FCN)。一年后,他想把资产转给在美国工作的儿子。
问题一次全来。原本该定期派息的债券基金大幅下跌,固定票息票据锁了好几年,而当终于有人用美国的角度审视这个账户时,才发现以父亲本人名义持有的美国股票属于美国境内资产(US-situs),超过 60,000 美元免税额的部分就暴露在美国遗产税之下——不管托管机构设在哪个国家。
你必须先知道目标是什么、规划是什么,再选架构,然后才决定买什么、用谁的名义买。
最后,这些投资被拆掉,在另一个持有架构下重建。花了大量时间,外加一笔本来根本不必付的交易成本。
正确的顺序
- 了解客户的个人与财务状况。画出家族资产负债表:每一项资产在哪里、用谁的名义、适用哪个国家的规则。每一位家人:谁是美国税务身份(US person)、谁是税务居民、谁可能搬去那里。
- 确认并选定目标。这笔钱是做什么用的、谁继承、要留多少流动性、要承担多少风险,以及有一天你无法做决定时,由谁来决定。
- 分析客户目前的行动方案与可能的替代方案。照现在的路走下去会到哪里?那是你想去的地方吗?
- 制定财务规划建议。根据目前的状况,哪些改变值得启动,让你的财务更到位。
- 提出财务规划建议。逐项详谈每个建议的利与弊,以及它对你的家庭为什么合理。
- 执行财务规划建议。由在相关司法管辖区执业的律师起草规划所需的文件:各国的遗嘱、必要时的信托,以及符合继承人未来居住地的持有方式。
- 跟踪进度并更新。在书面投资政策之下采用全权委托,按时检视。人生难免变动,该调就调——对外派与海外居住的家庭尤其如此!
这就是我自己的经历。我想先盘点资产、搭好架构,再投资。银行第一天就准备好要执行了。前面几步并不是被忽略,有人来简短谈了一下架构,然后话题很快又回到要买什么。
在 Avrio,我们对每一位客户都以受托人的身份服务。我们会和客户讨论目标、家庭状况、持有的护照等等。我们决定资产配置在哪里,挑选最符合客户需求的托管机构,然后执行规划。
出航之前,要准备的事很多。先走完一套系统化的流程,再离港,别让任何人催你。下次走进私人银行,不要急着签第一笔交易。问问你的银行家:这项投资怎么放进我整体的规划、目标和人生方向?你对客户承担信义义务吗?如果对方的回答让你迟疑,那就是该联系我们财富规划师的时候了。最好是在第一笔交易之前。
--
35 歲之前,我自己就成了私人銀行的客戶。那段經驗教了我很多。其中一課:銀行家不會告訴你,事情的先後順序有多重要。CFP 財務規劃流程給了一套準則:了解客戶、確認目標、分析行動方案、擬定財務規劃建議、提出財務規劃方案、執行建議,以及持續追蹤與更新。
如果你是準備繼承的第二代、第三代,或是正要為子女安排傳承,請放慢腳步,不要急著買產品,先想一想上面這個順序。
為什麼順序會被倒過來
大型私人銀行通常會指派一位客戶關係經理(RM),他負責的是你的帳戶,不是你的規劃。開戶文件把這一點寫得很明白:每一個決定都記錄為你自己做的,因為一般來說,銀行不負受託人義務,而 CFP 專業人士則負有受託人義務。
銀行的流程是圍著帳戶建立的,不是圍著你的家庭。先開戶,再選投資標的。目標、規劃、行動方案呢?沒有討論。有時候,後果要好幾年後才浮現——可能已經來不及了。
資產用錯了名義持有,或放錯了國家,可能帶來遺產稅、申報義務,或是和當地繼承規則的衝突。事後再補救,花的錢比任何人預算的都多。
我常看到的一種情況
一位 60 歲的企業主,公司在亞洲,工廠在東南亞,生意做得不錯,在新加坡一家私人銀行開了戶。第一個月內投資就買齊了:美國股票、幾檔高收益債券基金、一些固定票息票據(FCN)。一年後,他想把資產轉給在美國工作的兒子。
問題一次全來。原本該定期配息的債券基金大幅跌價,固定票息票據鎖了好幾年,而當終於有人用美國的角度檢視這個帳戶時,才發現以父親本人名義持有的美國股票屬於美國境內資產(US-situs),超過 60,000 美元免稅額的部分就暴露在美國遺產稅之下——不管託管機構設在哪個國家。
你必須先知道目標是什麼、規劃是什麼,再選架構,然後才決定買什麼、用誰的名義買。
最後,這些投資被拆掉,在另一個持有架構下重建。花了大量時間,外加一筆本來根本不必付的交易成本。
正確的順序
- 了解客戶的個人與財務狀況。畫出家族資產負債表:每一項資產在哪裡、用誰的名義、適用哪個國家的規則。每一位家人:誰是美國稅務身分(US person)、誰是稅務居民、誰可能搬去那裡。
- 確認並選定目標。這筆錢是做什麼用的、誰繼承、要留多少流動性、要承擔多少風險,以及有一天你無法做決定時,由誰來決定。
- 分析客戶目前的行動方案與可能的替代方案。照現在的路走下去會到哪裡?那是你想去的地方嗎?
- 擬定財務規劃建議。根據目前的狀況,哪些改變值得啟動,讓你的財務更到位。
- 提出財務規劃建議。逐項詳談每個建議的利與弊,以及它對你的家庭為什麼合理。
- 執行財務規劃建議。由在相關司法管轄區執業的律師起草規劃所需的文件:各國的遺囑、必要時的信託,以及符合繼承人未來居住地的持有方式。
- 追蹤進度並更新。在書面投資政策之下採用全權委託,按時檢視。人生難免變動,該調就調——對外派與海外居住的家庭尤其如此!
這就是我自己的經歷。我想先盤點資產、建好架構,再投資。銀行第一天就準備好要執行了。前面幾步並不是被忽略,有人來簡短談了一下架構,然後話題很快又回到要買什麼。
在 Avrio,我們對每一位客戶都以受託人的身分服務。我們會和客戶討論目標、家庭狀況、持有的護照等等。我們決定資產配置在哪裡,挑選最符合客戶需求的託管機構,然後執行規劃。
出航之前,要準備的事很多。先走完一套系統化的流程,再離港,別讓任何人催你。下次走進私人銀行,不要急著簽第一筆交易。問問你的銀行家:這項投資怎麼放進我整體的規劃、目標和人生方向?你對客戶負有受託人義務嗎?如果對方的回答讓你遲疑,那就是該聯絡我們財富規劃師的時候了。最好是在第一筆交易之前。
This material is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Additionally, you should consult with your Financial Advisor, Tax Advisor, or Attorney on your specific situation. The views expressed in the material are that of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of any market, regulatory body, State or Federal Agency, or Association. All efforts have been made to report or share true and accurate information. However, the information may become materially outdated or otherwise rendered incorrect due to subsequent new research or other changes, without notice. The author nor the firm are able to always verify the content from third-party sources. For additional information about the firm, please visit the MAS Website at https://www.mas.gov.sg/ and the SEC Website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. For a copy of the firm's ADV Part 2 Brochure, please contact us at info@avriowealth.com.